On this page
Our picks
Our picks
- 1OnPay: best for most small businesses$49/mo + $6 per worker
- 2Gusto: best for small businesses that want benefits too$49/mo + $6 per person
- 3Patriot Software: best for the lowest price with tax filing$37/mo + $5 per worker
- 4Square Payroll: best for small teams already using Square$35/mo + $6 per person
- 5QuickBooks Payroll: best for businesses already on QuickBooks Online$50/mo + $7 per employee
- 6Justworks: best for small businesses that may want a PEO later$50/mo + $8 per employee
- 7Rippling: best for small businesses that want HR and IT in one system$8 per user/mo + $40 base
- 8ADP RUN: best for businesses that want a large providerQuote only
- 9Paychex Flex: best for businesses that want a dedicated repQuote only
How we ranked
- 1Files and pays federal, state, and local payroll taxes on the base plan.
- 2Total monthly cost at list price for 10 employees in one state.
- 3Pays contractors and files 1099s without a separate product.
- 4Publishes what it does when it makes a tax filing error.
- 5Room to grow: a second state, HR tools, and benefits without switching providers.
Every price and feature comes from the provider's own pricing page, product page, help center, or terms, read October 27, 2026. List prices, before promotions. We didn't use review sites. Where a provider only gives quotes, we say so.
Payroll services compared
| Provider | Plan | Math | Per month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patriot | Full Service | $37 + 10 × $5 | $87 |
| Square | Full-service | $35 + 10 × $6 | $95 |
| OnPay | Payroll Essentials | $49 + 10 × $6 | $109 |
| Gusto | Simple | $49 + 10 × $6 | $109 |
| QuickBooks | Workforce Payroll | $50 + 10 × $7 | $120 |
| Rippling | Starting rate | $40 + 10 × $8 | $120 and up |
| Justworks | Payroll | $50 + 10 × $8 | $130 |
| ADP RUN, Paychex | Any | Quote only | Ask |
| Local taxes | Contractors | Error policy | Second state | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. OnPay | Included | |||
| 2. Gusto | Not stated | Plus plan | ||
| 3. Patriot | Most | $12/mo | ||
| 4. Square | Not found | Included | ||
| 5. QuickBooks | Premium and up | Elite only | $12/mo | |
| 6. Justworks | Not stated | $8 each | Not stated | Included |
| 7. Rippling | Blog only | Included | ||
| 8. ADP RUN | Extra | Included | ||
| 9. Paychex | New, terms not public | Not stated |
Buttoned
Payroll runs. The state accounts still need someone.
Rate notices, address changes, and agency letters come to you, not your provider. Buttoned keeps every account current and drafts each reply for you to approve.
#1 · Best for most small businesses
1. OnPay
OnPay sells one payroll plan, Payroll Essentials, with tax filings, W-2s and 1099s, and multi-state payroll included. HR and time tracking are add-ons.
From $49/mo + $6 per worker
Visit OnPay- Tax filing
- Federal, state, and local
- Contractors
- Same per-worker fee; 1099s included
- Second state
- No extra cost; registration included
- Free trial
- First month free
Per worker paid, W-2 or 1099. First month free.
Why it ranks #1
OnPay is the only provider here that passes every test on its base plan. It files federal, state, and local taxes, pays contractors at the same per-worker rate, publishes an error-free guarantee, and adds new states at no extra cost with automatic state tax registration. At $109 a month for 10 employees, it costs the same as Gusto's one-state plan.
Pros
- One plan with everything a small business needs.
- No fee for more states, and state registration included.
- Published error-free guarantee.
Cons
- No international payroll.
- HR tools are a paid add-on.
Choose OnPay if
- You want one simple price with taxes and year-end forms included.
- You might hire in another state.
#2 · Best for small businesses that want benefits too
2. Gusto
Gusto sells payroll with benefits and HR in three plans: Simple, Plus, and Premium.
From $49/mo + $6 per person
Visit Gusto- Tax filing
- Filings and payments on every plan
- Contractors
- Plan per-person fee, only in months paid
- Second state
- Needs Plus, $80 + $12 per person
- Setup
- Free, no contract
Simple, one state. Plus $80 + $12; Premium $180 + $22.
Why it ranks #2
Gusto Simple costs the same as OnPay for 10 people, $109 a month, with tax filings, contractor payments, and unlimited runs. It ranks second because Simple covers one state, so a second-state hire moves you to Plus at $80 + $12 per person. Its terms commit it to remit taxes and pay penalties when it files late. Its benefits and add-ons are the broadest here.
Pros
- Health insurance, 401(k), and other benefits built in.
- Free setup, month-to-month.
- Large set of add-ons, from same-day pay to compliance tracking.
Cons
- Multi-state payroll needs Plus, which doubles the per-person fee.
- State registration costs extra, priced by state.
Choose Gusto if
- You want to offer health benefits through your payroll provider.
- Your team is in one state for now.
#3 · Best for the lowest price with tax filing
3. Patriot Software
Patriot sells Basic Payroll, where you file taxes yourself, and Full Service Payroll, where Patriot files and deposits them.
From $37/mo + $5 per worker
Visit Patriot Software- Tax filing
- Federal, state, most local (Full Service)
- Second state
- $12/mo each
- Free trial
- 30 days
- Setup
- No setup fees
Full Service, one state included. Basic Payroll is $17 + $4 but doesn't file taxes.
Why it ranks #3
Full Service Payroll is $87 a month for 10 employees, the cheapest full-service price here. Patriot files federal, state, and most local taxes, and says it will take care of penalties and interest from a glitch on its end. It ranks third because each extra state costs $12 a month and new-state registration goes through a partner at extra cost.
Pros
- Lowest price for full-service payroll.
- Published penalty promise.
- Covers all 50 states and DC.
Cons
- $12 a month for each extra state.
- Fewer HR and benefits options than Gusto or OnPay.
Choose Patriot Software if
- Price matters most.
- You're in one or two states.
#4 · Best for small teams already using Square
4. Square Payroll
Square Payroll offers full-service payroll and a contractor-only plan, and works with Square's point of sale and team tools.
From $35/mo + $6 per person
Visit Square Payroll- Tax filing
- Federal and state, included
- Contractors
- Included; contractor-only plan $6 each
- New state
- You provide the state accounts
- Contract
- None
Full-service. Contractor-only: $6 per person paid.
Why it ranks #4
At $95 a month for 10 employees, Square is the second-cheapest here, with tax filings, off-cycle runs, and multistate payroll included. It ranks fourth because you must open every state tax account yourself, and it can't pay one employee who works in more than one tax jurisdiction. We found no published error policy.
Pros
- Low price with no per-state fee.
- Contractor-only plan for teams without employees.
- Works with Square point of sale.
Cons
- Won't register you in a new state.
- Can't split one employee across jurisdictions.
Choose Square Payroll if
- You run a shop or restaurant on Square.
- Your state accounts already exist.
#5 · Best for businesses already on QuickBooks Online
5. QuickBooks Payroll
QuickBooks Payroll, now sold as QuickBooks Workforce, has three payroll plans, alone or bundled with QuickBooks Online.
From $50/mo + $7 per employee
Visit QuickBooks Payroll- Local taxes
- Premium and Elite only
- Second state
- $12/mo on Payroll and Premium
- Penalty protection
- Elite only, up to $25,000 a year
Workforce Payroll. Premium $88 + $13; Elite $134 + $17.
Why it ranks #5
Workforce Payroll is $120 a month for 10 employees in one state. It ranks fifth because the base plan doesn't pay or file local taxes, each extra state is $12 a month, and penalty protection comes only with the $134 + $17 Elite plan. Its strength is the link with QuickBooks accounting.
Pros
- Payroll and books in one place.
- Payroll-only plans if you don't use QuickBooks Online.
Cons
- No local taxes on the base plan.
- Penalty protection only on the top plan.
Choose QuickBooks Payroll if
- You already run your books in QuickBooks Online.
#6 · Best for small businesses that may want a PEO later
6. Justworks
Justworks sells a Payroll plan and two PEO plans that give your team access to its group health plans.
From $50/mo + $8 per employee
Visit Justworks- Second state
- Included on every plan
- Contractors
- $8/mo each (U.S.)
- Setup
- No implementation fee
Payroll plan. PEO Basic $79 and PEO Plus $124 per employee.
Why it ranks #6
The Payroll plan is $130 a month for 10 employees, with multi-state payroll included. It ranks sixth on price and because U.S. contractors cost $8 each on top of employees. Its advantage is the path to a PEO for benefits without changing providers.
Pros
- Multi-state payroll on the cheapest plan.
- Easy move to a PEO and group health plans.
Cons
- Contractors cost extra.
- No published error policy on the pricing page.
Choose Justworks if
- You want group health benefits soon.
#7 · Best for small businesses that want HR and IT in one system
7. Rippling
Rippling sells payroll as one product on a platform that also covers HR, devices, apps, and global hiring.
From $8 per user/mo + $40 base
Visit Rippling- Second state
- No extra charge; automatic registration
- Outside the U.S.
- Global payroll and EOR
- Price
- Quote for the final figure
Starting rate; Rippling quotes the final price.
Why it ranks #7
Rippling's starting rate is $8 per user plus a $40 base, $120 for 10 people, but its own blog prices payroll on top of the core platform, so expect more. It ranks seventh for a small business that only needs payroll. For a team that also wants onboarding, devices, and global hiring in one place, it moves up.
Pros
- No per-state fee and automatic new-state registration.
- HR, IT, and payroll in one system.
Cons
- Final price needs a quote.
- More than a small team needs for payroll alone.
Choose Rippling if
- You'll hire abroad or want IT and HR tied to payroll.
#8 · Best for businesses that want a large provider
8. ADP RUN
RUN Powered by ADP is ADP's payroll for 1 to 49 employees, sold in four packages.
From Quote only
Visit ADP RUN- Tax filing
- Federal, state, and local
- Year-end forms
- Additional fee
- Contract
- Price may rise after 6 months
Why it ranks #8
ADP files federal, state, and local taxes, handles employees who work in more than one jurisdiction, and says it pays fines from its own filing errors. It ranks eighth because there's no published price, W-2s and contractor payments carry extra fees, and its contract allows price increases after six months.
Pros
- Handles multi-jurisdiction employees.
- Published penalty promise.
Cons
- No public prices.
- Extra fees for W-2s and contractors.
Choose ADP RUN if
- You want a long-established provider and are fine with a quote.
#9 · Best for businesses that want a dedicated rep
9. Paychex Flex
Paychex sells four small business payroll packages: Basic, Foundations, Advanced, and Complete.
From Quote only
Visit Paychex Flex- Tax filing
- Federal, state, and local
- Error policy
- Tax Penalty Protection (Flex), announced Oct. 19, 2026
Why it ranks #9
Paychex files federal, state, and local taxes automatically. On October 19, 2026 it announced Tax Penalty Protection for Paychex Flex customers, which covers penalties and interest on eligible issues, subject to terms and limits it hasn't published. It ranks last because prices are quote only and those terms aren't public yet.
Pros
- Large provider with HR and benefits to grow into.
Cons
- No public prices.
- Penalty protection terms and limits not published.
Choose Paychex Flex if
- You want a person to call and are fine with a quote.
What every payroll provider leaves to you
The IRS says the employer is ultimately responsible for depositing and paying federal payroll taxes, even when a provider handles them. See the IRS on outsourcing payroll duties.
- 01Keep your own address on file with the IRS. The IRS says not to change it to your provider's address, because its letters go to the address of record.
- 02Enroll in EFTPS, the Treasury's free payment system, and check that deposits are being made.
- 03Open every state account in your own name, and keep the logins.
- 04Read every agency letter yourself, even if the provider says it will handle it.
Which one fits your business
Choose OnPay if
- You want taxes, contractors, and new states included in one price
Choose Gusto if
- You want health benefits from your payroll provider
Choose Patriot if
- The lowest price with tax filing matters most
Choose Square if
- You already use Square and your state accounts exist
Choose QuickBooks if
- Your books are in QuickBooks Online
Choose Rippling if
- You want HR, IT, and global hiring with payroll
Where Buttoned fits
Buttoned doesn't run payroll, so it isn't on this list. It works next to whichever provider you choose.
Your provider files the returns. The accounts behind them are still yours: state registrations, unemployment rate notices, address changes, and the letters when something doesn't match. Buttoned keeps those current, and when an agency writes, we draft the reply for you to approve.
Common questions
What is the best payroll service for a small business?
For most small businesses, OnPay: one price with federal, state, and local taxes, contractors, and new states included. Gusto is better if you want benefits; Patriot is cheapest with tax filing.
How much does payroll cost for a small business?
At list price, $87 to $130 a month for 10 employees in one state among providers that publish prices. ADP and Paychex quote instead.
What is the cheapest payroll service with tax filing?
Patriot Full Service, at $37 a month plus $5 per worker. Square is next at $35 plus $6 per person.
Do payroll services file my taxes?
Full-service plans file and pay federal and state payroll taxes. Local taxes vary: QuickBooks' base plan doesn't file them, and Patriot covers most.
If my payroll provider makes a mistake, who pays the penalty?
The IRS holds the employer responsible. OnPay, Gusto, Patriot, and ADP publish promises or terms to pay penalties from their own errors; QuickBooks only on Elite.
Which payroll services include contractors?
OnPay, Gusto, Patriot, Square, QuickBooks, and Rippling pay contractors on their payroll plans. Justworks charges $8 per contractor, and ADP charges a contractor fee.
What do I need if I hire in a second state?
New state tax accounts, and a plan that covers more than one state. Gusto needs Plus; Patriot and QuickBooks charge $12 a month per extra state; OnPay and Rippling include it.
Can I switch payroll providers mid-year?
Yes. Switching at a quarter end is simplest, because quarterly returns and year-to-date totals line up.
Sources
- IRS: Outsourcing payroll duties
- OnPay: Pricing
- Gusto: Pricing
- Patriot Software: Pricing
- Square: Payroll pricing
- Square: Paying employees in different tax jurisdictions
- QuickBooks: Payroll pricing
- QuickBooks: Payroll disclosures
- Justworks: Pricing
- Rippling: Small business
- ADP: RUN payroll packages
- Paychex: Small business payroll
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.