At a glance
- What it is
- A sourcing rule: remote work days count where the office is
- Best known state
- New York
- Applies when
- The assigned or primary office is in the rule state and the home office is outside it
- Way out
- The home office is a bona fide employer office
- Who decides
- The state tax agency, using its published factors
What is the convenience of the employer rule?
It is a state income tax rule about where wages are earned. A nonresident is taxed on wages from work done in the state. The rule treats some work done at home elsewhere as done in the state.
The name misleads. It is not an employer policy. States apply it to employees, and it has nothing to do with whether your company allows remote work.
New York's regulation says allowances for days worked outside the state must be based on duties that "of necessity, as distinguished from convenience" obligate the employee to work out of state. That is where the name comes from.
How does New York apply it?
Per the Tax Department's TSB-M-06(5)I, normal work days spent at home count as New York work days if the employee's assigned or primary work location is a bona fide employer office in New York. A normal work day means a day the person performs the usual duties of the job. Answering the odd email does not count.
The memo says a home office outside New York is treated as outside only if it is a bona fide employer office. That means meeting the primary factor, or at least four of the secondary factors and three of the other factors. The primary factor is that the home office contains or is near specialized facilities the employer cannot provide at its own office. A secondary factor example is that the home office is a requirement or condition of employment.
| Route | What it takes |
|---|---|
| Primary factor alone | The home office contains or is near specialized facilities the employer cannot provide at its own office |
| Or: combination | At least 4 of the secondary factors and 3 of the other factors |
The Tax Department's nonresident FAQ says the same in short form: telecommuting days are generally treated as days worked in the state unless the employer has established a bona fide employer office at that location.
Which states use a convenience of the employer rule?
Lists online disagree, so use agency pages. New York's position is on its Tax Department site, as above.
New Jersey has no rule of its own. A 2023 law (P.L.2023, c.125) makes New Jersey apply the home state's rule to nonresidents. Its FAQ names Delaware, Nebraska, and New York, and says the list may change. It applies for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2023.
The same FAQ says Pennsylvania residents are excluded because of a reciprocal agreement, and Connecticut residents are excluded because Connecticut's law is reciprocal. For New Jersey employers, that carve-out matters.
We did not verify other states' own rules on their agency pages. Check the state's page before you rely on a list.
What does this mean for employers?
Three things. First, your employee may owe tax to a state where they never work, and the state may expect withholding on those wages. New Jersey's FAQ says New Jersey employers should withhold New Jersey Gross Income Tax on Delaware, Nebraska, and New York residents who work remotely for their own convenience.
Second, the employee's home state may also tax the wages, with a credit for the other state's tax on the employee's return. That is why employees sometimes see double withholding.
Third, payroll can end up with the wrong state in the system, either way. That is the problem described in wages reported to the wrong state.
This rule is about income tax. Unemployment tax follows a separate set of ordered tests.
Worked example (hypothetical)
A company's assigned office for an analyst is in New York. The analyst lives in another state and works from home four days a week because they prefer to, not because the company requires it. Under New York's memo, those four days count as New York work days unless the home office meets the bona fide employer office test.
If the company instead requires the employee to work from home in a written employment contract, that is one secondary factor. It is not enough alone. The home office needs the primary factor, or four secondary and three other factors.
If you're a remote employee, does this apply to you?
It can, if your employer's assigned or primary office for you is in a state with the rule and you work at home elsewhere by choice. Your pay stub may show tax withheld for the office state. Your home state may also tax the wages, usually with a credit on your return.
Ask your employer where your assigned office is and whether your home office was set up as an employer office. Keep a record of the days you worked in each place.
What should an employer do?
- 01Find out whether the employee's assigned or primary office is in a state with a rule like this.
- 02Ask the employee where they work on a normal day and how often they go to the office.
- 03Check the state agency's published factors before you claim a home office is a bona fide employer office.
- 04Write down the decision and the reason, and keep it with the payroll file.
- 05Set the employee's withholding in payroll to match. Re-check when the employee moves or the office changes.
For setup basics, see remote employee in another state and employee moved to another state.
If you'd rather hand this off, send us the letter. We'll check it against your account and draft the reply for you to approve.
Common questions
What is the convenience of the employer rule?
It treats days an employee works at home for their own convenience as days worked at the employer's office state, for income tax purposes.
Does the New York convenience rule apply to remote workers?
It can, when the assigned or primary office is in New York. Normal work days at home count as New York days unless the home office is a bona fide employer office.
How can a home office avoid the rule?
It must meet the primary factor (specialized facilities), or four secondary factors and three other factors, as New York's memo describes.
Which states use a convenience of the employer rule?
New York is confirmed on its agency pages. New Jersey applies the home state's rule to residents of Delaware, Nebraska, and New York. Check each state's tax agency.
What is the New York convenience rule?
It treats normal work days at home outside New York as New York work days when the assigned or primary office is in New York, unless the home office is a bona fide employer office.
Can I be taxed by two states under this rule?
Yes. Your home state may also tax the wages, usually with a credit for tax paid to the other state. Check both states.
Does the rule apply to unemployment tax?
No. It is an income tax sourcing rule. Unemployment tax follows its own ordered tests.
Sources
- New York Tax Department: TSB-M-06(5)I, Convenience of the Employer Test
- New York Tax Department: Nonresident FAQs
- New Jersey Division of Taxation: Convenience Rule FAQ
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.