At a glance
- Run by
- The IRS, decided case by case
- Test
- Ordinary care and prudence, and no willful neglect
- Examples that can work
- Disaster, serious illness, lost records, system failures
- Weak on their own
- Relying on a pro, not knowing, honest mistakes, lack of funds
- How to ask
- Call the notice number, or send a written request or Form 843
- Interest
- Removed if the penalty is removed
What is reasonable cause?
Reasonable cause means you had a good reason for the failure, and you acted in good faith. The IRS looks at all the facts and circumstances. There is no fixed list that guarantees a yes.
It can apply to failure-to-file, failure-to-pay, and failure-to-deposit penalties, and to others. It does not apply to some penalties, such as the estimated tax penalty.
For a business, the IRS looks at the person with authority to file the return, make the deposit, or pay the tax.
What reasons does the IRS accept?
For filing and payment penalties, you generally must show ordinary care and prudence and still not be able to comply. The IRS gives these examples:
- A fire, natural disaster, or civil disturbance.
- You could not get the records you needed.
- Death, serious illness, or unavoidable absence of you or an immediate family member.
- A system problem delayed a timely electronic filing or payment.
Show timing. The reason has to explain the lateness, and you should have fixed the problem quickly once it was over.
What reasons usually don't work?
The IRS says these factors generally do not qualify on their own:
- Relying on a tax professional. You are still responsible, so confirm what is filed and keep proof it was on time.
- Not knowing the rule. You are expected to know or ask.
- A mistake or oversight.
- Lack of funds. It is not enough alone, but other facts showing you tried to comply may help.
A payroll provider's error is not an automatic defense. See who pays when a payroll provider makes a mistake.
Which reasons work and which don't? A quick table
| Reason | How the IRS treats it | What to show |
|---|---|---|
| Fire, disaster, or civil disturbance | Listed as a valid example | Dated records or reports |
| Could not get records | Listed as a valid example | Proof you asked for them and when |
| Death, serious illness, or unavoidable absence | Listed as a valid example | A letter with start and end dates |
| System issue delayed e-filing or payment | Listed as a valid example | Error messages, confirmations, bank notices |
| Relied on a tax professional | Generally not enough alone | What you gave them and how you checked |
| Did not know the rule | Generally not enough alone | Steps you took to find out |
| Mistake or oversight | Generally not enough alone | Efforts to comply and to fix it |
| Lack of funds | Not enough by itself | Other facts that show care and an effort to pay |
How do I request penalty relief for reasonable cause?
- 01Gather the notice, the penalty you want removed, and your records.
- 02Write down what happened and when, how it kept you from filing or paying on time, and what you tried to do.
- 03Collect proof: a doctor's letter with start and end dates, disaster records, letters you sent and got, receipts or forms.
- 04Call the toll-free number in the top right corner of the notice, or send a written request. You can use Form 843 or a penalty abatement letter.
- 05Pay what you can now. Ask about a payment plan for the rest. A plan may reduce future penalties.
If you qualify for first time abate, the IRS applies that instead of reasonable cause.
What is the IRS standard for information return and accuracy penalties?
The test changes by penalty type. For information returns, the IRS says you must show you acted responsibly before and after the failure, and that there were significant mitigating factors or events beyond your control.
- Before: you asked for extensions when possible or tried to prevent a foreseeable late filing.
- After: you fixed the cause and corrected the failure as quickly as you could.
- Mitigating factors the IRS names: first-time filer of the form, good compliance history, actions by the IRS or another person, no access to business records, or economic hardship that blocked electronic filing.
For accuracy-related penalties, the IRS looks at your effort to report the right tax, how complex the issue was, your experience, and the steps you took to get advice. If you relied on an advisor, it asks whether you gave the advisor all the facts and whether the advisor was competent for the issue.
What does a strong reasonable cause case look like for payroll taxes?
Payroll cases usually turn on timing and records. The IRS says failure-to-deposit penalties do not apply if the failure was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect.
Two hypothetical examples show the difference. These are illustrations only.
- Stronger: a fire damaged the office and the payroll records in the week a deposit was due. The owner reported it, rebuilt the records, and made the deposit as soon as it was possible. Proof includes the incident report and dated emails.
- Weaker: the person who handled deposits was busy and forgot. There is no outside event, and the IRS lists mistakes and oversights as generally not enough on their own.
In both cases the IRS also looks at what you did next. Fixing the problem fast helps.
If you do not have a clean history, reasonable cause is often the main route. If you do, check first time penalty abatement first.
What if the IRS denies my reasonable cause request?
You can appeal. The IRS Appeals page says you generally have 30 days from the date of the rejection letter to request an appeal. Check your letter for the exact deadline.
To be eligible, you must have received a letter assessing a failure-to-file or failure-to-pay penalty, sent a written request to remove it, been denied, and received a denial letter that gives appeal rights.
Include proof of timely filing or payment if it applies. If neither applies, include a detailed explanation of the facts. Appeals can also consider a case that does not fit the usual examples.
What happens if I ignore the penalty notice?
The tax keeps growing while you wait. Interest builds daily on unpaid tax and penalties. A failure-to-pay penalty stays at 0.5% a month and rises to 1% if the tax is unpaid 10 days after a notice of intent to levy. A failure-to-deposit penalty can reach 15% once it is unpaid more than 10 days after the first IRS notice.
Send your request before the response date on the notice. See failure to file vs. failure to pay for the full rates.
What if the IRS says no?
The denial notice explains your options, including an appeal. You can authorize a representative with Form 2848. You can also contact the Taxpayer Advocate Service if you cannot resolve it yourself.
In July 2026 the IRS said people who do not qualify for its new automatic relief can still ask for reasonable cause relief. See automatic IRS penalty relief.
If you'd rather hand this off, send us the letter. We'll check it against your account and draft the reply for you to approve.
Common questions
What is a reasonable cause letter?
It is a written explanation of why you could not comply on time. It states what happened, when, how it stopped you, and what you did to fix it, with proof attached.
Does reasonable cause apply to payroll tax penalties?
Yes. The IRS says failure-to-deposit penalties do not apply if the failure was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect.
Is lack of money reasonable cause?
Not by itself. Other facts that show you used care and tried to comply may support your request.
Can I use reasonable cause if I relied on my accountant?
Reliance on a tax professional generally does not qualify alone. The IRS expects you to confirm what is filed and get proof it was on time.
Is interest removed with the penalty?
Yes. If a penalty is reduced or removed, the related interest is too.
Do I need a reasonable cause letter or can I call?
You can call the number on your notice first. If the IRS cannot approve relief by phone, you can send a written request or Form 843.
How long do I have to appeal a denial?
Generally 30 days from the date of the rejection letter, according to the IRS Appeals page. Check your letter for the exact date.
What happens if I don't respond to a penalty notice?
Interest keeps building, and the failure-to-pay and failure-to-deposit penalties can rise after a notice of intent to levy or a demand. Respond before the date on your notice.
Sources
- IRS: Penalty relief for reasonable cause
- IRS: Administrative penalty relief (First Time Abate and AEP)
- IRS: Failure to deposit penalty
- IRS: Penalty relief
- IRS: Penalty appeal
- IRS: Failure to pay penalty
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.