At a glance
- What it is
- An optional extra payment to the state fund
- Goal
- A lower unemployment tax rate
- Allowed in
- About half of states, per the U.S. Department of Labor
- Deadline
- Set by the state, and within 120 days of the rate year start under federal law
- Refund
- Generally none, even if your rate does not drop
What is a voluntary SUI contribution?
It is a payment above your regular tax. You send it to the state, and the state counts it in the formula that sets your rate. The U.S. Department of Labor says about half of states allow it.
It is not a donation or a prepayment. The goal is a lower rate that saves more than the payment costs.
How does it lower your rate?
It depends on how the state sets rates. The Department of Labor describes two common methods.
- Reserve ratio states: the payment adds to your account balance, which can move you to a lower rate.
- Benefit ratio states: the payment cancels benefit charges against your account, which lowers your benefit ratio.
Whether it is worth it depends on your rate table. Many states publish the schedule. Compare the cost of the payment with the tax you would save.
What are the rules and risks?
Federal law requires that the payment be made earlier than 120 days after the rate year begins. Some states set earlier due dates. Some are due in February or March, so plan ahead.
Federal law restricts refunds to erroneous payments. If the payment does not lower your rate, or you change your mind, you generally cannot get it back.
States can add limits. Some say you cannot have unpaid balances. Some cap how many rate steps you can move. Read the state's rules before you pay.
Do not send a voluntary payment without confirming the exact amount, the deadline, and the written process with your state agency.
How do you decide?
- 01Find out if your state allows voluntary contributions.
- 02Get the rate table and your current account balance or benefit ratio from the state.
- 03Work out how much the payment would lower your rate, and what that saves over the year.
- 04Check the deadline and the state's required statement identifying it as voluntary.
- 05Pay only the amount the agency tells you, by the deadline.
For the basics, see how SUI rates are set. You can also review your state rate notice.
What is a worked example of a voluntary contribution?
Hypothetical example, not a real state schedule. Say you have eight employees, the wage base is $10,000, and each earns at least that. Taxable wages are $80,000.
If a voluntary payment moved you down one rate step of 0.5%, the savings would be $400 for the year. The payment would need to cost less than $400 to be worth it. If it costs $450, you lose money.
| Payment | Yearly savings | Result |
|---|---|---|
| $300 | $400 | Ahead by $100 |
| $400 | $400 | Break even |
| $450 | $400 | Behind by $50 |
A benefit-ratio state works differently. There the payment cancels charges on your account, so the saving depends on how much that changes your ratio. Ask the state to calculate it for you.
What does one state's process look like?
New Jersey is one example. The state says you can make a voluntary additional contribution to have your experience rating recalculated, using Form UC-45. See New Jersey SUI tax.
Other states have their own forms and cutoffs. The Department of Labor's table lists the due date and conditions for each state that allows it.
What are common mistakes?
- Paying after the deadline, so it does not count.
- Paying an amount the state did not calculate, and getting no rate change.
- Forgetting that unpaid balances can make you ineligible in some states.
- Assuming a refund is available if the rate does not drop.
- Not labeling the payment as voluntary when the state requires it.
Is it right for every employer?
Not always. It tends to make sense only if your rate would drop by enough to beat the payment. If you are close to the next rate tier, it may be worth a look. If not, skip it.
This is general information, not tax advice. If you want a second set of eyes on a state letter, send it to us. We'll check it against your account and draft the reply for you to approve.
Common questions
Can I buy down my SUI rate?
In about half of states, yes, through a voluntary contribution. Check your state's rules.
Do I get a refund if it does not lower my rate?
Generally no. Federal law limits refunds to erroneous payments.
When must I pay?
By a deadline set by your state. Federal law requires it within 120 days of the start of the rate year, and some states set it earlier.
Do all states accept voluntary contributions?
No. States that do not allow it will not accept it. Others limit how much it can reduce your rate.
Is the voluntary contribution deductible?
That is a tax question. Ask your tax adviser.
What is a buy down of SUI rate?
It is a common name for a voluntary contribution that lowers your state unemployment rate.
What forms are used?
It depends on the state. New Jersey uses Form UC-45 for a voluntary additional contribution.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor: Comparison of State UI Laws, Financing (2023 edition)
- IRS: Instructions for Form 940
- NJ Division of Employer Accounts: bills and notices
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.