On this page
Our picks
Our picks
- 1Poppins Payroll: best for most families$49/mo
- 2GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay): best for a written penalty guarantee$70/mo
- 3HomePay (Care.com): best for families who want agency notices handled$59/mo
- 4SurePayroll: best for the lowest monthly price$39/mo
- 5HomeWork Solutions: best for choosing how much to hand off$59/mo
How we ranked
- 1Monthly price for one employee, plus setup and year-end fees.
- 2Includes tax account registration, quarterly filings, W-2, and Schedule H.
- 3Written guarantee for filing errors.
- 4Contract terms: cancel anytime or a minimum.
Prices from each provider's own pricing page, read October 27, 2026. Tax rules from IRS Publication 926 (2026).
When you're a household employer
IRS Publication 926 says Social Security and Medicare taxes apply when you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026. You report them on Schedule H with your Form 1040, and give your employee a W-2. Federal unemployment tax applies if you pay $1,000 or more in cash wages in any calendar quarter. Your state has its own unemployment and withholding rules.
Nanny payroll prices compared
| Service | Monthly | Setup and year-end | Contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poppins Payroll | $49 | No setup costs; registration included | Cancel anytime |
| GTM EasyPay | $70 + $20 per extra employee | Setup included | One-month minimum |
| HomePay (Care.com) | $59 Essentials, $75 Plus | Registration included | Not stated |
| SurePayroll | $39 ("now only") | Not stated | Cancel anytime |
| HomeWork Solutions | $59, $95, or $155 | $120 enrollment + $130 year-end | Cancel anytime |
Buttoned
Running a business too?
Household payroll covers your nanny. Your company's state accounts and agency letters are a different job. Buttoned keeps those current and drafts each reply for you to approve.
#1 · Best for most families
1. Poppins Payroll
Poppins Payroll is household payroll with one plan: pay, tax filings, and agency communication.
From $49/mo
Visit Poppins Payroll- Registration
- Federal, state, and local, included
- Contract
- Cancel anytime
First month free; no setup costs.
Why it ranks #1
Poppins charges $49 a month with no setup costs and no tiers, and you can cancel anytime. The plan includes federal, state, and local tax account registration, new-hire reporting, and communication with tax agencies. The first month is free. It ranks first because it includes the most for a low, simple price.
Pros
- One simple plan.
- Tax registration included.
Cons
- No written penalty guarantee on the pricing page.
Choose Poppins Payroll if
- You want it handled for one low price.
#2 · Best for a written penalty guarantee
2. GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay)
GTM sells household payroll from EasyPay up to plans with HR and benefits help.
From $70/mo
Visit GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay)- Guarantee
- Pays penalties and fines if GTM is at fault
- Minimum
- One month (EasyPay)
EasyPay; $20 per extra employee. HR Platinum $132, Diamond $232 (12-month minimum, $75 setup).
Why it ranks #2
EasyPay starts at $70 a month with tax IDs, filings, and audit support, plus $20 for each extra employee, with a one-month minimum. GTM's guarantee says it will work with the agency on any notice from a filing it made and pay the penalties and fines if it's at fault. It ranks second on price.
Pros
- Strong written guarantee.
- Setup included on EasyPay.
Cons
- Higher plans need a 12-month minimum.
Choose GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay) if
- You want penalty protection in writing.
#3 · Best for families who want agency notices handled
3. HomePay (Care.com)
HomePay is Care.com's household payroll and tax service, with Essentials and Plus plans.
Why it ranks #3
Essentials is $59 a month with federal and state tax registration and quarterly filings. Plus, at $75 with the first month free, adds account management, tax agency notice management, and a Care.com membership. HomePay says it acts as your tax agent with the state. It ranks third on price.
Pros
- Acts as your tax agent.
- Notice handling on Plus.
Cons
- Notice handling only on the higher plan.
Choose HomePay (Care.com) if
- You want agency letters handled for you.
#4 · Best for the lowest monthly price
4. SurePayroll
SurePayroll, backed by Paychex, offers a Nanny & Household Payroll plan.
Why it ranks #4
SurePayroll shows "Now only $39/month" and a 6-months-free offer, billed monthly with cancel anytime. It ranks fourth because the offer terms sit in a separate Terms and Conditions page, and its page doesn't say what's included at setup or year-end.
Pros
- Lowest listed price.
Cons
- Promotional price; terms on a separate page.
Choose SurePayroll if
- Price matters most and you're comfortable with self-service.
#5 · Best for choosing how much to hand off
5. HomeWork Solutions
HomeWork Solutions sells three household payroll plans in all 50 states.
From $59/mo
Visit HomeWork Solutions- Extra fees
- $120 enrollment, $130 year-end
Guided; Complete $95; Premier $155. Plus $120 enrollment and $130 year-end.
Why it ranks #5
Plans are $59, $95, or $155 a month, and you can cancel anytime. It ranks last because it adds a $120 enrollment fee for tax registration and new-hire reporting and a $130 year-end fee for the W-2 and Schedule H, which others include.
Pros
- Three levels of service.
- All 50 states.
Cons
- Separate enrollment and year-end fees.
Choose HomeWork Solutions if
- You want the top tier of hands-off service.
Common questions
Do I need to pay taxes for my nanny?
If you pay $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026, yes: Social Security and Medicare, reported on Schedule H. Federal unemployment applies at $1,000 in a quarter.
How much does a nanny payroll service cost?
$39 to $75 a month for one employee at the published prices here, plus setup or year-end fees at some providers.
What's the cheapest nanny payroll service?
SurePayroll lists $39 a month as a promotional price. Poppins is $49 with registration included.
Do nanny payroll services file Schedule H?
They prepare it, along with the W-2. You file Schedule H with your Form 1040.
Can I use regular payroll software for a nanny?
Some providers support household employers, but nanny services include household-specific steps like Schedule H.
Sources
- IRS: Publication 926 (2026)
- Poppins Payroll: Pricing
- GTM: Household pricing
- HomePay: Product and pricing
- SurePayroll: Household payroll
- HomeWork Solutions: Plans and pricing
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.