Best nanny payroll services, ranked for 2026.

If you pay a nanny $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026, you owe Social Security and Medicare taxes as a household employer. A nanny payroll service runs pay, files the taxes, and prepares the W-2 and Schedule H. Poppins Payroll ranks first: $49 a month with tax registration included and no contract. GTM has the strongest written penalty guarantee.

By Updated October 2026Prices checked on vendor pages
On this page
  1. Our picks
  2. How we ranked
  3. When you're a household employer
  4. Nanny payroll prices compared
  5. 1. Poppins Payroll
  6. 2. GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay)
  7. 3. HomePay (Care.com)
  8. 4. SurePayroll
  9. 5. HomeWork Solutions
  10. Common questions

Our picks

Our picks

  1. 1Poppins Payroll: best for most families$49/mo
  2. 2GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay): best for a written penalty guarantee$70/mo
  3. 3HomePay (Care.com): best for families who want agency notices handled$59/mo
  4. 4SurePayroll: best for the lowest monthly price$39/mo
  5. 5HomeWork Solutions: best for choosing how much to hand off$59/mo

How we ranked

  1. 1Monthly price for one employee, plus setup and year-end fees.
  2. 2Includes tax account registration, quarterly filings, W-2, and Schedule H.
  3. 3Written guarantee for filing errors.
  4. 4Contract terms: cancel anytime or a minimum.

Prices from each provider's own pricing page, read October 27, 2026. Tax rules from IRS Publication 926 (2026).

When you're a household employer

IRS Publication 926 says Social Security and Medicare taxes apply when you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026. You report them on Schedule H with your Form 1040, and give your employee a W-2. Federal unemployment tax applies if you pay $1,000 or more in cash wages in any calendar quarter. Your state has its own unemployment and withholding rules.

Nanny payroll prices compared

One employee, list price, read October 27, 2026
ServiceMonthlySetup and year-endContract
Poppins Payroll$49No setup costs; registration includedCancel anytime
GTM EasyPay$70 + $20 per extra employeeSetup includedOne-month minimum
HomePay (Care.com)$59 Essentials, $75 PlusRegistration includedNot stated
SurePayroll$39 ("now only")Not statedCancel anytime
HomeWork Solutions$59, $95, or $155$120 enrollment + $130 year-endCancel anytime

Buttoned

Running a business too?

Household payroll covers your nanny. Your company's state accounts and agency letters are a different job. Buttoned keeps those current and drafts each reply for you to approve.

#1 · Best for most families

1. Poppins Payroll

Poppins Payroll is household payroll with one plan: pay, tax filings, and agency communication.

Registration
Federal, state, and local, included
Contract
Cancel anytime

First month free; no setup costs.

Why it ranks #1

Poppins charges $49 a month with no setup costs and no tiers, and you can cancel anytime. The plan includes federal, state, and local tax account registration, new-hire reporting, and communication with tax agencies. The first month is free. It ranks first because it includes the most for a low, simple price.

Pros

  • One simple plan.
  • Tax registration included.

Cons

  • No written penalty guarantee on the pricing page.

Choose Poppins Payroll if

  • You want it handled for one low price.

#2 · Best for a written penalty guarantee

2. GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay)

GTM sells household payroll from EasyPay up to plans with HR and benefits help.

Guarantee
Pays penalties and fines if GTM is at fault
Minimum
One month (EasyPay)

EasyPay; $20 per extra employee. HR Platinum $132, Diamond $232 (12-month minimum, $75 setup).

Why it ranks #2

EasyPay starts at $70 a month with tax IDs, filings, and audit support, plus $20 for each extra employee, with a one-month minimum. GTM's guarantee says it will work with the agency on any notice from a filing it made and pay the penalties and fines if it's at fault. It ranks second on price.

Pros

  • Strong written guarantee.
  • Setup included on EasyPay.

Cons

  • Higher plans need a 12-month minimum.

Choose GTM Payroll Services (EasyPay) if

  • You want penalty protection in writing.

#3 · Best for families who want agency notices handled

3. HomePay (Care.com)

HomePay is Care.com's household payroll and tax service, with Essentials and Plus plans.

Notices
Managed on Plus

Essentials. Plus $75, first month free.

Why it ranks #3

Essentials is $59 a month with federal and state tax registration and quarterly filings. Plus, at $75 with the first month free, adds account management, tax agency notice management, and a Care.com membership. HomePay says it acts as your tax agent with the state. It ranks third on price.

Pros

  • Acts as your tax agent.
  • Notice handling on Plus.

Cons

  • Notice handling only on the higher plan.

Choose HomePay (Care.com) if

  • You want agency letters handled for you.

#4 · Best for the lowest monthly price

4. SurePayroll

SurePayroll, backed by Paychex, offers a Nanny & Household Payroll plan.

Year-end
Download Schedule H and W-2

"Now only"; offer terms apply.

Why it ranks #4

SurePayroll shows "Now only $39/month" and a 6-months-free offer, billed monthly with cancel anytime. It ranks fourth because the offer terms sit in a separate Terms and Conditions page, and its page doesn't say what's included at setup or year-end.

Pros

  • Lowest listed price.

Cons

  • Promotional price; terms on a separate page.

Choose SurePayroll if

  • Price matters most and you're comfortable with self-service.

#5 · Best for choosing how much to hand off

5. HomeWork Solutions

HomeWork Solutions sells three household payroll plans in all 50 states.

Extra fees
$120 enrollment, $130 year-end

Guided; Complete $95; Premier $155. Plus $120 enrollment and $130 year-end.

Why it ranks #5

Plans are $59, $95, or $155 a month, and you can cancel anytime. It ranks last because it adds a $120 enrollment fee for tax registration and new-hire reporting and a $130 year-end fee for the W-2 and Schedule H, which others include.

Pros

  • Three levels of service.
  • All 50 states.

Cons

  • Separate enrollment and year-end fees.

Choose HomeWork Solutions if

  • You want the top tier of hands-off service.

Common questions

Do I need to pay taxes for my nanny?

If you pay $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026, yes: Social Security and Medicare, reported on Schedule H. Federal unemployment applies at $1,000 in a quarter.

How much does a nanny payroll service cost?

$39 to $75 a month for one employee at the published prices here, plus setup or year-end fees at some providers.

What's the cheapest nanny payroll service?

SurePayroll lists $39 a month as a promotional price. Poppins is $49 with registration included.

Do nanny payroll services file Schedule H?

They prepare it, along with the W-2. You file Schedule H with your Form 1040.

Can I use regular payroll software for a nanny?

Some providers support household employers, but nanny services include household-specific steps like Schedule H.

Sources

This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.

Your back office, buttoned up.

Got a letter, or hiring in a new state? Tell us where you operate and send any letters you have. Within one business day you get back what you owe, to whom, and by when, plus a drafted reply for any letter.

Flat fee, quoted before any work starts.