Payroll for nonprofits: the two rules that differ, and the providers compared.

Nonprofit payroll is mostly the same as any other employer's. Two things differ for 501(c)(3) organizations. They generally don't owe federal unemployment tax (FUTA). And federal law requires states to let them reimburse unemployment benefits instead of paying state unemployment tax. Your payroll provider has to handle both correctly.

By Updated October 2026Checked against official sources

At a glance

FUTA
501(c)(3) organizations generally don't owe it
State unemployment
Can elect to reimburse instead of paying tax
Still owed
Income tax withholding, Social Security, Medicare
Still filed
Form 941 each quarter, W-2s each year
Provider check
Does it support FUTA exemption and reimbursing status?

What's different for a 501(c)(3)

Nonprofit payroll rules
Item501(c)(3) organizationSource
Federal unemployment tax (FUTA)Generally not owed, so generally no Form 940Form 940 instructions
State unemploymentMay elect to reimburse benefits paid instead of paying tax26 U.S.C. 3309
Federal income tax withholdingSame as any employerIRS employment taxes
Social Security and MedicareSame as any employerIRS employment taxes

The FUTA exemption has a catch. A 501(c)(3) that pays wages on behalf of a non-501(c)(3) organization, such as a related group, owes FUTA on those wages.

Reimbursing vs. paying state unemployment tax

Federal law requires each state to let nonprofits choose. A contributing employer pays state unemployment tax every quarter, like a business. A reimbursing employer pays nothing up front, then repays the state for unemployment benefits paid to its former employees.

Reimbursing can cost less if you rarely lay people off. It can cost much more after a layoff. States set the election rules and how long you stay in, so check with your state before you choose.

Hypothetical example, not a real case: a 12-person nonprofit elects to reimburse. For three years nobody files a claim, and it pays nothing. Then two staff are laid off when a grant ends, and the state bills it for their full benefits.

Payroll providers for nonprofits

The general payroll providers serve nonprofits too. Prices are the same as for businesses. See payroll services compared for the full table.

  • Ask each provider whether it marks the organization as FUTA-exempt, so it doesn't collect FUTA you don't owe.
  • Ask whether it supports reimbursing status in your state, so it doesn't calculate state unemployment tax.
  • Ask how it handles employees paid from more than one grant, if you need to split costs.

What a provider still leaves to you

The IRS is direct about this: the employer is ultimately responsible for depositing and paying federal payroll taxes, even when a provider handles them. If a provider misses a payment, the IRS can charge the penalties and interest to you.

  1. 01Keep your own address on file with the IRS. The IRS says not to change it to your provider's address, because its letters go to the address of record.
  2. 02Enroll in EFTPS, the Treasury's free payment system, and check that deposits are being made. The IRS says a missed or late payment should be a red flag.
  3. 03Open every state account in your own name, and keep the logins.
  4. 04Read every agency letter yourself, even if the provider says it will handle it.

Whichever provider you pick, agency letters still come to you. If you'd rather hand those off, connect your payroll. We'll watch every account, and draft each reply and filing for you to approve.

Common questions

Do nonprofits pay payroll taxes?

Yes. They withhold income tax and pay Social Security and Medicare like any employer. 501(c)(3) organizations generally don't owe FUTA.

Do 501(c)(3) organizations file Form 940?

Generally no, because they generally aren't subject to FUTA tax. They still file Form 941 each quarter.

What is a reimbursing employer?

A nonprofit that repays the state for unemployment benefits its former employees receive, instead of paying state unemployment tax each quarter.

What is the best payroll service for nonprofits?

One that supports FUTA exemption and reimbursing status in your state, at a price that fits. The main providers all serve nonprofits.

Sources

This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.

Your back office, buttoned up.

Got a letter, or hiring in a new state? Tell us where you operate and send any letters you have. Within one business day you get back what you owe, to whom, and by when, plus a drafted reply for any letter.

Flat fee, quoted before any work starts.