On this page
ADP vs Paychex at a glance
| ADP RUN | Paychex Flex | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Quote only | Quote only |
| Small business packages | Essential, Enhanced, Complete, HR Pro | Basic, Foundations, Advanced, Complete |
| Tax filing | Federal, state, local | Federal, state, local |
| Tax penalties | Pays penalties from ADP errors (in its terms) | Tax Penalty Protection, any cause, eligible issues; terms not public |
| Support | 24/7 payroll supportEdge | Varies by line and package |
| Contract | Fees can rise after 6 months, 30 days' notice | Promotion needs a 1-year agreement |
| Current promotion | Up to 6 months free (banner ends 11/26) | Free payroll through April 2027; ends 10/31 |
From ADP's and Paychex's own pages and terms, read October 27, 2026.
Tax penalties
ADP's packages page says that if it makes a tax filing error, it pays the resulting fines or penalties, and its RUN terms back that up.
On October 19, 2026, Paychex announced Tax Penalty Protection Service for Paychex Flex customers. Paychex says it takes on eligible payroll tax issues regardless of cause, including customer and agency errors, and covers penalties and interest that remain after it works with the agency. Coverage is subject to terms, conditions, and limits Paychex hasn't published. Comparison pages written before that date say Paychex has no penalty coverage; they're out of date.
Buttoned
Either way, the state accounts are still yours.
Registrations, rate notices, address changes, and agency letters don't move to your provider. Buttoned keeps them current and drafts each reply. You approve every submission.
Contracts and promotions
ADP's RUN terms let it raise base fees after six months with 30 days' notice. ADP advertises up to 6 months free.
Paychex's offer credits payroll fees through April 2027 for new clients who sign a one-year service agreement on Foundations or higher by October 31, 2026. Basic doesn't qualify. See Paychex pricing and ADP pricing.
Which one to choose
Choose ADP if
- You want 24/7 payroll support
- You want the penalty promise in your contract
Choose Paychex if
- You want help with agency notices whatever caused them
- The free months and a one-year agreement suit you
If you'd rather see a price before you talk to sales, see the best payroll services for small business.
Whichever you pick, the state accounts behind payroll stay in your name, and agency letters come to you. Buttoned keeps those accounts current and drafts each reply for you to approve.
Common questions
Is ADP or Paychex cheaper?
Neither publishes prices. Get written quotes with year-end fees included and compare them.
Does Paychex pay tax penalties?
Since October 19, 2026, Paychex Flex customers can get Tax Penalty Protection for eligible issues, subject to terms and limits Paychex hasn't published.
Does ADP pay tax penalties?
ADP says it pays fines or penalties caused by its own tax filing errors.
Does Paychex require a contract?
Its current promotion requires a one-year service agreement. Standard Flex terms aren't published.
Which has 24/7 support?
ADP lists 24/7 payroll support on its RUN packages page.
Sources
- ADP: RUN payroll packages
- ADP: RUN terms of service
- Paychex: Small business payroll
- Paychex: Tax Penalty Protection announcement
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.