On this page
Our picks
Our picks
- 1OnPay: best for most small businesses$49/mo + $6 per worker
- 2Gusto: best for benefits without a contract$49/mo + $6 per person
- 3Patriot Software: best for the lowest price$37/mo + $5 per worker
- 4ADP RUN: best for another large providerQuote only
- 5Rippling: best for a modern HR system$8 per user/mo + $40 base
- 6QuickBooks Payroll: best for QuickBooks Online users$50/mo + $7 per employee
How we ranked
- 1Published price.
- 2No long contract.
- 3Multi-state payroll and local taxes.
- 4Published error policy.
Prices and features from each vendor's own pricing or product page, read October 27, 2026. List prices, before promotions.
Why people switch
These are individual posts from public forums, not a survey. They show the reasons people give when they leave.
- Quote-only pricing that's hard to compare.
- Add-ons offered to employees, such as insurance and HSA products.
- Outgrowing it, especially with mixed hourly and salaried staff.
Paychex alternatives compared
| Provider | Starting price | Contract |
|---|---|---|
| OnPay | $49/mo + $6 per worker | Not stated on pricing page |
| Gusto | $49/mo + $6 per person | Month-to-month |
| Patriot | $37/mo + $5 per worker | Monthly |
| ADP RUN | Quote only | Fees can rise after 6 months |
| Rippling | $8 per user + $40 base | Quote |
| QuickBooks | $50/mo + $7 per employee | Not stated on pricing page |
Buttoned
Switching providers? Your state accounts don't move.
Registrations, rate notices, and agency letters stay in your name through a switch. Buttoned keeps them current and drafts each reply for you to approve.
#1 · Best for most small businesses
1. OnPay
OnPay sells one payroll plan with tax filings, W-2s and 1099s, multi-state payroll, and state tax registration included.
From $49/mo + $6 per worker
Visit OnPay- More states
- No extra cost; registration included
- Error policy
- Published error-free guarantee
Per worker paid, W-2 or 1099. First month free.
Why it ranks #1
OnPay publishes one plan with federal, state, and local filings, multi-state payroll, and an error-free guarantee: $109 a month for 10 people.
Pros
- One published price with multi-state included.
- Published error-free guarantee.
Cons
- No international payroll.
Choose OnPay if
- You want a simple price and room for new states.
#2 · Best for benefits without a contract
2. Gusto
Gusto runs payroll with benefits and HR, in Simple, Plus, and Premium plans.
From $49/mo + $6 per person
Visit Gusto- Contract
- Month-to-month, free setup
- Second state
- Plus plan
Simple, one state. Plus $80 + $12; Premium $180 + $22.
Why it ranks #2
Gusto is month-to-month with free setup, from $49 plus $6 per person.
Pros
- Published prices, no contract.
- Benefits and HR built in.
Cons
- Multi-state needs Plus.
- State registration is extra.
Choose Gusto if
- You want benefits from your payroll provider.
#3 · Best for the lowest price
3. Patriot Software
Patriot sells Basic Payroll, where you file taxes, and Full Service Payroll, where Patriot files and deposits them.
From $37/mo + $5 per worker
Visit Patriot Software- Setup
- No setup fees
Full Service; $12/mo per extra state.
Why it ranks #3
Patriot Full Service is $37 plus $5 per worker, with local taxes and a tax filing guarantee.
Pros
- Lowest full-service list price.
- Tax filing reliability guaranteed on Full Service.
Cons
- $12 a month per extra state.
- Lighter HR and benefits.
Choose Patriot Software if
- Price matters most.
#4 · Best for another large provider
4. ADP RUN
RUN Powered by ADP is ADP's payroll for 1 to 49 employees, in four packages.
From Quote only
Visit ADP RUN- Support
- 24/7 payroll support
- Tax errors
- Pays fines or penalties from its errors
Why it ranks #4
If you want a big provider but not Paychex, ADP RUN lists 24/7 payroll support and pays penalties from its own filing errors. It quotes too.
Pros
- 24/7 support.
- Multi-jurisdiction payroll in every package.
Cons
- No public prices.
- Extra fees for W-2s.
Choose ADP RUN if
- You want round-the-clock support.
#5 · Best for a modern HR system
5. Rippling
Rippling runs payroll inside a platform that also covers HR, devices, apps, and global hiring.
From $8 per user/mo + $40 base
Visit Rippling- More states
- No extra charge; automatic registration
Starting rate; quote for the final price.
Why it ranks #5
For teams outgrowing Paychex's HR tools, Rippling adds HR, devices, and global hiring with no per-state fee.
Pros
- No per-state fee.
- HR, IT, and global in one system.
Cons
- Final price needs a quote.
Choose Rippling if
- You want one system for HR, payroll, and IT.
#6 · Best for QuickBooks Online users
6. QuickBooks Payroll
QuickBooks Payroll, now QuickBooks Workforce, sells three payroll plans alone or with QuickBooks Online.
From $50/mo + $7 per employee
Visit QuickBooks Payroll- Penalty protection
- Elite only, up to $25,000 a year
Premium $88 + $13; Elite $134 + $17.
Why it ranks #6
QuickBooks Workforce Payroll is $50 plus $7 per employee and syncs with your books.
Pros
- Built into QuickBooks Online.
Cons
- No local taxes on the base plan.
Choose QuickBooks Payroll if
- Your books are in QuickBooks Online.
Before you leave Paychex
- 01Download every quarterly return, year-to-date payroll report, and tax payment record from Paychex.
- 02Switch at a quarter end if you can, so quarterly returns and year-to-date totals line up.
- 03Confirm who files the current quarter's returns and the W-2s for this year, in writing.
- 04Keep your own logins for every state tax account, and your address current with each agency.
Where Buttoned fits
Buttoned doesn't run payroll, so it isn't on this list. It works next to whichever provider you choose.
A switch is when state accounts slip: a new provider files under the wrong number, or a rate notice goes to the old one. Buttoned keeps every account current and drafts each reply for you to approve.
Common questions
What is the best alternative to Paychex?
OnPay for a published price with multi-state included; Gusto for benefits; ADP for another large provider.
Is Gusto cheaper than Paychex?
Paychex doesn't publish prices. Gusto starts at $49 plus $6 per person; compare that with your Paychex quote.
Does Paychex have a contract?
Its current free-months promotion requires a one-year service agreement.
Does Paychex pay tax penalties?
Paychex announced Tax Penalty Protection on October 19, 2026 for Flex customers, with terms it hasn't published.
Sources
- Paychex: Small business payroll
- OnPay: Pricing
- Gusto: Pricing
- Patriot Software: Pricing
- ADP: RUN packages
- Rippling: Small business
- QuickBooks: Payroll pricing
This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.