Gusto alternatives, ranked for small businesses.

Gusto's Simple plan covers one state, and multi-state payroll doubles the per-person fee on Plus. OnPay ranks first: the same $49 a month plus $6 per worker, with more states and state registration included. Patriot is cheaper, and Rippling fits if you're outgrowing Gusto.

By Updated October 2026Prices checked on vendor pages
On this page
  1. Our picks
  2. How we ranked
  3. Why people switch
  4. Gusto alternatives compared
  5. 1. OnPay
  6. 2. Patriot Software
  7. 3. Square Payroll
  8. 4. Justworks
  9. 5. Rippling
  10. 6. QuickBooks Payroll
  11. Before you leave Gusto
  12. Where Buttoned fits
  13. Common questions

Our picks

Our picks

  1. 1OnPay: best for the same price with more included$49/mo + $6 per worker
  2. 2Patriot Software: best for a lower price$37/mo + $5 per worker
  3. 3Square Payroll: best for Square businesses$35/mo + $6 per person
  4. 4Justworks: best for group health benefits through a PEO$50/mo + $8 per employee
  5. 5Rippling: best for outgrowing Gusto$8 per user/mo + $40 base
  6. 6QuickBooks Payroll: best for QuickBooks Online users$50/mo + $7 per employee

How we ranked

  1. 1Price compared with Gusto at the same team size.
  2. 2Multi-state payroll without a plan upgrade.
  3. 3Published error policy.
  4. 4What it does better than Gusto.

Prices and features from each vendor's own pricing or product page, read October 27, 2026. List prices, before promotions.

Why people switch

These are individual posts from public forums, not a survey. They show the reasons people give when they leave.

  • Price increases, including on the 401(k) partner.
  • Support when a state filing or registration partner fails.
  • Workers' comp and 401(k) add-ons going wrong.
  • Outgrowing it with staff in other countries.
“their service has completely disappeared while their base costs increase”
A customer of 3.5 years on r/smallbusiness, September 2026

Gusto alternatives compared

15 employees, list price, read October 27, 2026
ProviderOne stateFour states
Gusto$139 (Simple)$260 (Plus)
OnPay$139$139
Patriot$112$148
Square$125$125
Justworks$170$170
QuickBooks$155$191

Buttoned

Switching providers? Your state accounts don't move.

Registrations, rate notices, and agency letters stay in your name through a switch. Buttoned keeps them current and drafts each reply for you to approve.

#1 · Best for the same price with more included

1. OnPay

OnPay sells one payroll plan with tax filings, W-2s and 1099s, multi-state payroll, and state tax registration included.

From $49/mo + $6 per worker

Visit OnPay
More states
No extra cost; registration included
Error policy
Published error-free guarantee

Per worker paid, W-2 or 1099. First month free.

Why it ranks #1

OnPay costs exactly what Gusto Simple does, $49 plus $6 per worker, but includes multi-state payroll and state tax registration on that one plan. For 15 people in 4 states it's $139 a month against $260 on Gusto Plus.

Pros

  • One published price with multi-state included.
  • Published error-free guarantee.

Cons

  • No international payroll.

Choose OnPay if

  • You want a simple price and room for new states.

#2 · Best for a lower price

2. Patriot Software

Patriot sells Basic Payroll, where you file taxes, and Full Service Payroll, where Patriot files and deposits them.

From $37/mo + $5 per worker

Visit Patriot Software
Setup
No setup fees

Full Service; $12/mo per extra state.

Why it ranks #2

Patriot Full Service is $112 a month for 15 people in one state, $27 less than Gusto Simple, and says it guarantees tax filing reliability.

Pros

  • Lowest full-service list price.
  • Tax filing reliability guaranteed on Full Service.

Cons

  • $12 a month per extra state.
  • Lighter HR and benefits.

Choose Patriot Software if

  • Price matters most.

#3 · Best for Square businesses

3. Square Payroll

Square Payroll offers full-service payroll and a contractor-only plan that works with Square's point of sale.

From $35/mo + $6 per person

Visit Square Payroll
New states
You provide the state accounts

Contractor-only $6 per person paid.

Why it ranks #3

Square is $125 a month for 15 people in any number of states. You must open each state tax account yourself.

Pros

  • Low price, no per-state fee.

Cons

  • Won't register new states.
  • Can't split one employee across jurisdictions.

Choose Square Payroll if

  • You run on Square and your state accounts exist.

#4 · Best for group health benefits through a PEO

4. Justworks

Justworks sells a Payroll plan and two PEO plans with access to group health insurance.

From $50/mo + $8 per employee

Visit Justworks
More states
Included on every plan
Setup
No implementation fee

Payroll. PEO Basic $79, PEO Plus $124 per employee.

Why it ranks #4

Justworks includes multi-state payroll on every plan and offers PEO plans for group health at $79 or $124 per employee.

Pros

  • Published PEO prices.
  • Multi-state on every plan.

Cons

  • U.S. contractors cost $8 each in months you pay them.

Choose Justworks if

  • You want group health benefits.

#5 · Best for outgrowing Gusto

5. Rippling

Rippling runs payroll inside a platform that also covers HR, devices, apps, and global hiring.

From $8 per user/mo + $40 base

Visit Rippling
More states
No extra charge; automatic registration

Starting rate; quote for the final price.

Why it ranks #5

Rippling covers what Gusto users outgrow: global hiring, devices, and deeper HR, with no per-state fee. The price is quoted.

Pros

  • No per-state fee.
  • HR, IT, and global in one system.

Cons

  • Final price needs a quote.

Choose Rippling if

  • You want one system for HR, payroll, and IT.

#6 · Best for QuickBooks Online users

6. QuickBooks Payroll

QuickBooks Payroll, now QuickBooks Workforce, sells three payroll plans alone or with QuickBooks Online.

From $50/mo + $7 per employee

Visit QuickBooks Payroll
Penalty protection
Elite only, up to $25,000 a year

Premium $88 + $13; Elite $134 + $17.

Why it ranks #6

QuickBooks charges $12 a month per extra state instead of a plan upgrade, so it's cheaper than Gusto Plus for small multi-state teams.

Pros

  • Built into QuickBooks Online.

Cons

  • No local taxes on the base plan.

Choose QuickBooks Payroll if

  • Your books are in QuickBooks Online.

Before you leave Gusto

  1. 01Download every quarterly return, year-to-date payroll report, and tax payment record from Gusto.
  2. 02Switch at a quarter end if you can, so quarterly returns and year-to-date totals line up.
  3. 03Confirm who files the current quarter's returns and the W-2s for this year, in writing.
  4. 04Keep your own logins for every state tax account, and your address current with each agency.

Where Buttoned fits

Buttoned doesn't run payroll, so it isn't on this list. It works next to whichever provider you choose.

A switch is when state accounts slip: a new provider files under the wrong number, or a rate notice goes to the old one. Buttoned keeps every account current and drafts each reply for you to approve.

Common questions

What is the best alternative to Gusto?

OnPay: the same $49 plus $6 per worker with multi-state payroll and state registration included.

What's cheaper than Gusto?

Patriot Full Service at $37 plus $5 per worker, and Square at $35 plus $6 per person.

Is there a Gusto alternative for multiple states?

OnPay, Square, Justworks, and Rippling don't charge more for more states. Gusto needs Plus.

Why do people leave Gusto?

Forum posts mention price increases, slow support when filings fail, and add-on problems. They're individual reports.

Can I switch from Gusto mid-year?

Yes. A quarter end is simplest.

Sources

This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.

Your back office, buttoned up.

Got a letter, or hiring in a new state? Tell us where you operate and send any letters you have. Within one business day you get back what you owe, to whom, and by when, plus a drafted reply for any letter.

Flat fee, quoted before any work starts.