Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: which costs less for your team?

Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person; QuickBooks Workforce Payroll is $50 plus $7. Gusto is cheaper at every size in one state. QuickBooks' base plan doesn't file local taxes, and its penalty protection, up to $25,000 a year, comes only on Elite. Pick QuickBooks if your books already live in QuickBooks Online.

By Updated October 2026Prices checked on vendor pages
On this page
  1. Gusto vs QuickBooks at a glance
  2. What each costs
  3. Which one to choose
  4. Common questions

Gusto vs QuickBooks at a glance

GustoQuickBooks Payroll
Entry plan$49/mo + $6 per personEdge$50/mo + $7 per employee
Middle plan$80 + $12Edge$88 + $13
Top plan$180 + $22$134 + $17Edge
Second stateNeeds Plus$12/mo per state on the two lower plans
Local taxesNot stated on the pricing pageNot on the entry plan; certain local taxes on Premium
Penalty promiseIn terms, every planEdgeUp to $25,000 a year, Elite only
AccountingIntegrationsBuilt into QuickBooks OnlineEdge
ContractMonth-to-monthMonthly; 50% off base for 3 months often

From Gusto's and Intuit's own pricing pages, read October 27, 2026.

What each costs

Entry plans at list price, one state
TeamGusto SimpleQuickBooks Workforce Payroll
5 people$79$85
15 people$139$155
50 people$349$400

In more states the math flips for small teams: Gusto needs Plus ($260 for 15 people), while QuickBooks adds $12 per state ($191 for 15 people in 4 states). See Gusto pricing and QuickBooks Payroll pricing.

Buttoned

Either way, the state accounts are still yours.

Registrations, rate notices, address changes, and agency letters don't move to your provider. Buttoned keeps them current and drafts each reply. You approve every submission.

Which one to choose

Choose Gusto if

  • You're in one state
  • You want a penalty promise on the cheapest plan
  • You want benefits from your payroll provider

Choose QuickBooks Payroll if

  • Your books are in QuickBooks Online
  • You're in several states with a small team

Whichever you pick, the state accounts behind payroll stay in your name, and agency letters come to you. Buttoned keeps those accounts current and drafts each reply for you to approve.

Common questions

Is Gusto cheaper than QuickBooks Payroll?

In one state, yes: $49 + $6 per person against $50 + $7. In several states, QuickBooks' $12-a-state fee can come out cheaper than Gusto Plus.

Does QuickBooks Payroll file local taxes?

Not on Workforce Payroll, the entry plan. Premium and Elite handle certain local taxes.

Which has penalty protection?

Gusto's terms cover penalties from Gusto's errors on every plan. QuickBooks offers up to $25,000 a year on Elite only.

Can I use Gusto with QuickBooks Online?

Yes, through an integration. QuickBooks Payroll is built in.

Sources

This guide explains how the rules work in general. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.

Your back office, buttoned up.

Got a letter, or hiring in a new state? Tell us where you operate and send any letters you have. Within one business day you get back what you owe, to whom, and by when, plus a drafted reply for any letter.

Flat fee, quoted before any work starts.